Martin Roth Christian Commentary

HOME About This Website Archives Read My Book Online Contact

Society & Culture
Christians and War
Southern Gospel Beat
Rowan Forster's Articles

Global Christianity
Around the World
Persecuted Church

Christian Living
Living Like Jesus
Church Life, Christian Life
Christian Parenting

Praying the Psalms
Australian Spirituality


Christian Blogging

Indian Religions

About Martin Roth
Favourite Links



War, Just War and Christians


Some reflections:


* Anti-American sentiment is apparently rising fast in South Korea. My wife is Korean. A few days ago one of her best friends said: “It’s good news that North Korea has a nuclear bomb. They won’t use it on South Korea, and it’ll make America less arrogant.” It seems this feeling is quite widespread in South Korea. Scary.


* World War II was generally seen as a just war (at least, if you were on the side of the Allies). But, since then, many church leaders have affirmed that the introduction of nuclear weapons makes it impossible to label as “just” any war at all, because of the risk of nuclear conflict. Here’s a suggestion: the advent of new high-tech, precision weaponry – used in the last conflict against Iraq and in Afghanistan – has reintroduced proportionality to warfare. Might it not be time for these church leaders to give war a chance?


* When you start reading your Bible you have trouble finding where the concept of a just war derives. As I wrote a few days ago, in my commentary Just War, Christians and Iraq – Where Is the Justice in Not Attacking?, “it’s hard to avoid the suspicion that Christian just war theory is simply an attempt to circumvent the clear teachings of Jesus”.


* And yet God loves soldiers. As in Old Testament days, He still apparently guides troops in battle.


* I have been fascinated to read the doctoral thesis of Father Patrick Dolan, a chaplain to the Kentucky National Guard. (Titled “Just War Theory in the Gulf War Debate”, it is not available commercially, or online, but is apparently found in many seminary libraries.) Writing about the last Gulf conflict, he says:


The use of power, whether it be economic or military, served a spiritual purpose: it communicated with Iraq and its people in their own spiritual language. Some have claimed that different world cultures value different spiritual entities. Some examples include…South Americans and other Latin cultures treasuring friendship of one who is simpatico while Northern Europeans and North Americans reverence truths….Power is the spiritual language of the Middle East. It is not just an acquiescence to a “might makes right” state of affairs; it is a reverencing of power – a holy attribute – as a sharing in one characteristic of “the Almighty One”.


Military power as spiritual language! That’s something church leaders anywhere can understand.


November 1st, 2002

See Also

War, Just War and Christians

South Koreans welcome North Korea's nuclear bomb, the spirituality of military power, and other reflections.
November 1st, 2002

Just War, Christians and Iraq – Where Is the Justice in Not Attacking?

Haven't the people of Iraq suffered enough?
October 29th, 2002


Does God Still Speak to Soldiers?

In Old Testament times God spoke regularly to Israel’s military commanders, directing their battles and bringing about the defeat of their enemies. But what about today? Does God still take sides?

September 21st, 2002


Onward Christian Soldiers (Part II)

Can a senior military officer truly follow Jesus and still be an efficient and effective soldier? An emphatic “yes” is the answer from Major General Tim Cross of the British Army

September 13th, 2002


Onward Christian Soldiers

God loves soldiers. Christians should, too.

September 9th, 2002

Attack on Iraq – Just War or Just Plain Wrong?

The Anglican Bishop to the Australian Defence Forces says it is time to rethink just war doctrines.

August 6th, 2002